Filth Bike vs ATV: 12 Execs and Cons of every sport


As an Amazon Affiliate DirtBikePlanet.com earns from qualifying purchases.

There are good causes to decide on dust bikes, and different good causes for selecting an ATV to your off-roading toy.  One is just not clearly higher than the opposite as a result of it is dependent upon what you wish to get from the game.  Nevertheless, hopefully this publish will level you in the appropriate course.

On the whole, I like to recommend dust bikes to anybody who needs a thrill experience that’s simpler to move and extra enjoyable to grasp long-term.  I like to recommend ATVs for somebody who needs to make use of the car as a hauling software, to take leisurely rides round whereas tenting, and who needs to study the game rapidly.  

I’ll clarify a number of the greatest variations under.

Filth Bikes Are Safer than Quads

This truth surprises many individuals, however it’s true that the dying fee from ATV using is considerably greater than that of dust bikes. There are mainly two the reason why ATVs are extra harmful: (1) The extra secure platform of an ATV offers the rider a false sense of safety, and (2) The 1,000 pound ATV is extraordinarily hazardous in a wreck as a result of it typically rolls over the rider.

An ATV feels extra regular than a mud bike.  It stands by itself and is straightforward to discover ways to experience initially.  This provides riders a false sense of safety.  They go too quick, they attempt to nook to rapidly and go over uneven surfaces, and it may well result in accidents.  In truth, even helmet utilization is much decrease amongst ATV riders than dust bikers; nevertheless, even for those who take the decrease proportion of helmet use on ATVs under consideration, ATVs are nonetheless much more lethal in a crash than dust bikes.  Whereas ATVs might really feel extra secure, they flip regularly.  The middle of gravity of an ATV is just too excessive, and it causes rollovers.

Riders on dust bikes break bones and are injured regularly.  Nevertheless, in a mud bike crash, the rider is normally thrown away from the bike.  Even when the bike does hit the rider, a mud bike normally weighs below 200 kilos.  ATV accidents are scary.  Even going sluggish over an uneven floor may cause them to flip and trigger a shifting 1,000 pound steel weight to fall on prime of the rider.

One other attention-grabbing level is that ATVs are particularly harmful for riders below the age of 16.  Statistically, children are far safer on dust bikes than 4 wheelers.  Why?  As a result of mother and father regularly have children using ATVs which might be the improper dimension for them.  When junior is 10 year-old and wishes a brand new ATV, mother and father too generally simply purchase a full-size ATV so that they gained’t must spend one other $10,000 on one other one when he outgrows it.  For those who do select ATVs and you’ve got children, NEVER allow them to experience an ATV that’s improperly sized for them.  Statistically, it is a large hazard.

I wrote a full publish on dust bike security that explains way more on this matter and has some intriguing statistics.

Quads Have a Longer Season

4 wheelers have an extended season than dust bikes–interval.  A dust bike is hopeless on snow or ice, however a quad an truly do fairly nicely in gentle snow.  If you wish to do any cold-weather using, then an ATV is a a lot better alternative as a result of it will get extra traction and is extra secure on flat floor.

Remember, nevertheless, that using within the winter is COLD.  Not solely is the surface temperature already chilly, however you will have the wind blowing in opposition to you making it much more bitter.

Filth Bikes Value Lower than Quads

Let’s check out some calmly used dust bikes and ATVs and see what the worth variations are:

  • A brand new mid-grade Honda ATV prices about $7,300 whereas a mid-grade Honda dirt-bike prices about $4,500 new.
  • A brand new mid-grade Suzuki ATV prices about $8,500 whereas a mid-grade Suzuki dust bike prices about $7,700 new.
  • A 2002 Honda Rancher 4 wheeler prices $3,000 on Craigslist, whereas you will get a comparable 2002 dust bike for round $1,500.
  • A four-year-old mid-grade Honda ATV is promoting for $4,700 on Craigslist, whereas a comparable Honda dust bike of the identical yr is promoting for about $3,000.

These are only a few examples, however suffice it to say that you simply’ll spend more cash on shopping for an ATV.

ATVs Crash Lower than Filth Bikes

If you wish to simply take pleasure in leisurely rides round trails or on the farm and don’t wish to push the boundaries, then a 4 wheeler is clearly your best choice.  Though crashes on ATVs are extra severe, they’re much less prone to happen.  If you gained’t be leaping, going quick, or pushing the boundaries and simply need a leisurely experience, then an ATV is a a lot better possibility.

Filth Bikes Can Run on Single Monitor

In my view, probably the most enjoyable components about off-roading is taking the little trails all around the mountains and out into areas that will be tough or inconceivable to succeed in with out an off-road car.  Lots of these tracks in Idaho are single-track, which means the path is barely as broad as a deer path.  Because of this quads can’t experience on the entire tracks {that a} dust bike can.

ATVs Are Simpler to Study

For those who hop on an ATV with 5 minutes of instruction and simply wish to go for a experience, you’ll just do advantageous.  On a mud bike, you’ll want extra instruction and it’ll take you a number of days earlier than you actually really feel like you possibly can comfortably experience with out excited about the bike.

Additionally, you stand a a lot decrease likelihood of crashing in your first experience on an ATV, the place that could be a probably state of affairs when using a mud bike for the primary time.

Filth Bikes Are Simpler to Haul

I wish to go using with my two boys.  I can simply match our three dust bikes at the back of a truck to go using.  There is no such thing as a method that will occur with ATVs due to their giant dimension.

Hauling one ATV isn’t any more durable than hauling one dust bike, however for those who’ll be using as a household or with mates, remember the fact that hauling them is far more durable.

Filth Bikes Are Extra of an Adrenaline Rush

ATVs simply aren’t made for adrenaline.  Certain, you possibly can go quick in a straight line identical to you possibly can on a mud bike; nevertheless, leaping an ATV is nothing like leaping a light-weight dust bike.  Cornering on a mud bike is far sooner than an ATV as nicely.

The very fact is that dust bikes are a much better adrenaline sport than ATVs.  ATVs can definitely be ridden onerous, however more often than not they aren’t.

ATVs Are Extra Useful

4 wheelers are a much better software for looking, tenting, farming, and so forth.  It’d be powerful to hold an elk out on the again of a mud bike.  The one solution to haul issues on a mud bike is to place it right into a backpack.  So if you wish to carry a single gun or a bow, you’re advantageous.  If you wish to deliver a small tent and camp out, you’re advantageous.  However if you wish to use it as a small truck, then a mud bike is a horrible alternative.

Filth Bikes Weigh Far Much less

A full-size grownup dust bike weighs below 200 kilos, whereas a full-size ATV weighs about 1,000 kilos.  This makes shifting ATVs round more durable, loading them more durable, makes them much less protected, and so forth.

The burden of the car additionally adjustments how they’re ridden.  A dust bike may be tipped nearly horizontal when cornering with out falling.  An ATV, nevertheless, may be very harmful whether it is tipped in any respect as a result of the rider’s weight is just not sufficient to manage the momentum of the quad.

ATVs Can Carry Passengers

ATV riders regularly carry passengers.  Whereas the overwhelming majority of ATVs are literally solely single-rider machines that ought to not have a passenger for security causes, many individuals do it anyway.  Filth bikes are at all times single-rider.  I nonetheless see dads taking their children out for a sluggish experience on dust bikes, however it’s principally a 1-rider affair.

So Which Ought to You Choose?

Clearly, I’m fairly keen on dust bikes given the subject of this web site, however there are good causes to decide on each.  If you wish to go on leisurely rides or use your off-roader as a useful software, then get an ATV.  If it is a enjoyable toy to experience round and study and get higher at, then select the safer and easier-to-haul dust bike.